Basically, the possibilities with this underrated pencil shade are endless, and if youre ready to add one to your current lineup, weve rounded up some of our favorites below for your consideration. Limited shade range India Knight recommended the L'Oreal gel eyeliner for waterline staying power last weekend in the Sunday Times. It's only £4.99. This one is a fan favorite among customers and Sephora employees alike. "This is the best eyeliner I have found in my 30 years of wearing eyeliner," shared an in-store customer at Sephora. "The Sephora saleswomen at midtown NYC location unanimously told me this was the best, long lasting eyeliner in their store." This product is cruelty-free. Read a BuzzFeeder’s review of this eyeliner! The clip, shared on Thursday and already watched more than 2.9 million times, was captioned "Why not to wear eyeliner on your waterline."